Video of Police Beating Student Draws Condemnation
Source: The Canadian Press
Posted: 10/16/09 8:46AM
Filed Under: Canada
LONDON, Ont. - A startling video of a University of Western Ontario student being pummelled by half-a-dozen police officers drew condemnation from some of the tens of thousands of people who watched it online Thursday as school officials defended what they called a necessary use of force.
The one minute and 32 second video, posted on YouTube, shows the student being held down in a campus building hallway Wednesday. Campus police and officers from the London, Ont., force are seen kneeing the student aggressively in the torso, repeatedly beating him on the back with batons and punching him hard.
At least one officer is heard yelling "Stop resisting," and then, "Give us your arm."
Many in the online community reacted to the stark images with horror and anger, and the school's student council said some students were expressing concern that such a violent takedown occurred in their halls. But the school warned that the video does not tell the whole story.
News That Stunned Us
Dr. Jonathan Burns, with his Pixalere device, used by four health authorities in B.C. and earning Burns's company hundreds of thousands of dollars a year.
(Abbotsford News)
Police say they're investigating the deaths of three newborns found in a Calgary home. The infants were discovered Sunday, Oct. 4, while Calgary police were investigating the death of a 27-year-old woman at a home in the 200 block of Taracove Estates Drive N.E., police said in a release Thursday evening. The deaths are considered "suspicious in nature," they said.
CBC News
A Calgary father who left his toddler alone in a van outside a casino in March has been sentenced to house arrest. Firefighters found the boy in a van outside the Silver Dollar Casino in Calgary.
CBC
France's Minister of Culture Frederic Mitterrand attends the question Government session at the National Assembly in Paris. Mitterrand denied Thursday paying boys for sex, in an impassioned response to critics on the right and left demanding that he resign over a candid book recounting encounters with male prostitutes in Thailand.
AP
Zakaria Amara pleaded guilty Thursday to charges related to the Toronto 18 terrorist plot to set off three fertilizer bombs at three targets in Ontario, including the CN Tower.
THE CANADIAN PRESS/Kevin Frayer
Cathie Gauthier, left, is escorted from the detention centre to a van on her way to the courthouse Wednesday, Oct.7, 2009 in Saguenay Que. Gauthier faces three counts of first-degree murder in the deaths of 12-year-old Joelle, seven-year-old Marc-Ange and four-year-old Louis-Philippe.
THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jacques Boissinot
Police cars sit outside a house in Saguenay, Que., Saturday, Jan. 3, 2009. A suicide pact between a Quebec couple was at the root of a family tragedy that left the husband and their three children dead and the wife facing three counts of first-degree murder, police said.
THE CANADIAN PRESS/ Chicoutimi Le Quotidien
Marc Laliberte, 46, is shown in this undated handout photo. A suicide pact between a Quebec couple was at the root of a family tragedy that left the husband and their three children dead and the wife facing three counts of first-degree murder, police said Saturday. The woman, only identified as the 36-year-old mother of the Laliberte clan, was recovering in hospital with an unspecified injury and will likely be charged Monday, said Sgt. Richard Gagne of the Quebec provincial police. Gagne said police have determined Marc Laliberte and his wife planned to commit suicide after killing their three children.
THE CANADIAN PRESS/Montreal La Presse-HO
A Calgary-area truck driver found guilty of manslaughter in a 2007 crash that killed two adults and three children has been sentenced to eight years in prison. Kiarra Gautreau, 6, and Alexia Gautreau, 9, above, as well as Zachary Morrison, 16 months, died in the December 2007 crash.
CBC News
Provincial court Judge Bruce Fraser sentenced Daniel Tschetter, 51, on Wednesday morning, also banning him for life from holding a licence that would allow him to drive a commercial vehicle. Tschetter, right, leaves court, in Calgary Thursday, May 7, 2009, with his wife after being found guilty of five counts of manslaughter after a cement truck crashed into the back of a car on Dec. 7, 2007, killing all five people inside.
THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jeff McIntosh
The student, identified by London police as 22-year-old Irnes Zeljkovic, was "creating safety concerns" and had barricaded himself inside a room, said Elgin Austen, the head of campus police.
The incident began on the seventh and eighth floors of the social sciences building, well before the video was shot, and "eventually, everything came down to the main floor," where efforts were made to subdue a "disoriented individual," he said.
"What the officers were doing was trying to apprehend a strong individual ... and not injure that person and keep other people around safe," said Austen, who added he didn't see "anything out of order" with the level of force.
"It was being conducted consistent with the Ontario Police College and the training that officers have there."
The Day in Photos
Sean Tucker flies his Oracle Challenger bi-plane inverted over US Marine Corps Major Nathan Miller, flying F/A-18 Blue Angel #5 Thursday, Oct. 8, 2009, over San Francisco Bay. The U. S. Navy's Flight Demonstration Squadron Blue Angels and Tucker are preparing for two air shows this weekend for Fleet Week San Francisco 2009 festivities, which celebrate the area's long naval history.
AP Photo/Ben Margot
South Korean actress Hwang Eun-jung poses during an opening ceremony of the Pusan International Film Festival in Busan, South Korea, Thursday, Oct. 8, 2009. One of Asia's top film festivals opened Thursday by taking a lighthearted look at the South Korean presidency.
AP Photo/Ahn Young-joon
Washington Capitals' Nicklas Backstrom (19), of Sweden, celebrates with teammate Brooks Laich, left, after scoring against the New York Rangers during the third period of an NHL hockey game, Thursday, Oct. 8, 2009, in Washington. Rangers won 4-3.
AP Photo/Manuel Balce Ceneta
Palestinian children visiting the Marah Land Zoo outside Gaza City look at a donkey painted in a zebra-like pattern,Thursday, Oct . 8, 2009. Zoo keepers have found a creative way to draw crowds to the Gaza zoo that suffered losses during the war with Israel. Zoo workers replaced 2 zebras that died of hunger during the January war with donkeys painted black and white.
AP Photo/Hatem Moussa
Chairperson of the Norwegian Nobel Committee, Thorbjorn Jagland, with pictures of Nobel Peace Prize laureate 2009 Barack Obama at The Norwegian Nobel Institute in Oslo Friday, Oct 9, 2009.
AP Photo/Torbjorn Gronning
Bianca Del Carretto of Italy, center, celebrates with her teammates after her victory over Laura Flessel-Colovic of France during the Fencing World Championships in the Women's Team Epee semi final event in Antalya, Turkey, Thursay, Oct. 8 , 2009.
AP Photo/Burhan Ozbilici
The Dalai Lama presents actor Richard Gere with a Khata during the International Campaign for Tibet 2009 Light of Truth Award in Washington, Wednesday, Oct. 7, 2009.
AP Photo/Susan Walsh
Masked gunmen fire a volley of shots over the coffin of Republican John Brady, outside his sister's home in Strabane, Northern Ireland, Thursday Oct. 8, 2009. Brady, 40, hanged himself in a police cell last Saturday after being arrested over a domestic dispute while on weekend parole from prison, and it was claimed that he could not face the prospect of returning to jail.
AP Photo/Peter Morrison
People watch a fight between monkeys with a dog at a roadside in Lahore, Pakistan on Tuesday, Oct. 6, 2009. These entertainment shows are usually seen in Pakistani rural areas and spectators offer money to owners of these animals. These fights are generally for entertainment and avoid serious injuries to participants.
AP Photo/K.M.Chaudary
A model presents a creation by Australian fashion designer Collette Dinnigan for her Spring Summer 2010 ready-to-wear collectionin Paris Wednesday, Oct. 7, 2009.
AP Photo/Christophe Ena
While the video is "disturbing" the incident needs to be kept in context, said university spokeswoman Gitta Kulczycki.
The main concern of police was protecting students and faculty, she said.
"The view of the video itself is somewhat disturbing without knowing the context of the full situation."
Zeljkovic, described as about 6 foot 2 inches and more than 200 pounds, was taken to hospital for observation, then released into custody.
The London, Ont., resident was charged with mischief under $5,000, assaulting a peace officer, resisting arrest and escaping lawful custody and was released after a court appearance Thursday.
The incident has raised concerns among students at the school, student council spokeswoman Carolyn Hawthorn said in an interview.
"Students are reacting to what they've seen on the video and most are reacting with concern," Hawthorn. "We're encouraging students to review all the facts and to seek out the full information."
No students have come forward to say they're worried about their personal safety, said Hawthorn, who added it's clear the video doesn't tell the whole story.
The video had received more than 32,000 hits on YouTube by late-Thursday afternoon. Most postings criticized police for their use of force.
One comment posted on YouTube from mitchkocz03 writes "homeboy got Rodney King'd" - a reference to the beating of Rodney King by Los Angeles police in 1991, an incident also caught on video that triggered riots in the city.
Another identified as teenager17 said, "I agree, this looks frighteningly reminiscent of the Rodney King beating, though it probably didn't go on for as long."
Another viewer wrote: "After watching it several times, there's little doubt in my mind that the police used excessive force."
"There's no way that five cops should have to use the amount of excessive force they did to 'detain' this person. To take out a billyclub and senselessly beat someone you have pinned down seems completely unnecessary!" wrote dpoe89.
Still, others in the online community said they felt police were within their rights.
"The same people who will cry here about cops using some kind of force are the same morons who will ask 'where were the cops when the guy went crazy?' Smazz104 wrote on YouTube.
"Cops did their job."
A spokeswoman for the province's Special Investigations Unit, which probes incidents involving serious injury or death to members of the public involving the police, said the unit is not investigating the incident.
Kulczycki said the school conducts an automatic review in situations like these.
"We will certainly co-operate fully with London police as that occurs," she said.
-By Alan Black and Pat Hewitt in Toronto
100 %
0 %
