Report Slams Tory Plans for U.S.-Style Prisons
Source: CBC News
Posted: 09/24/09 8:08AM
Filed Under: Canada
The Conservative government plans to bring in an American-style prison system that will cost billions of taxpayer dollars and do little to improve public safety, according to a report to be released Thursday in Ottawa.
The 235-page report, A Flawed Compass, is a scathing review of the government's plan, which it calls "immoral, unethical and illegal."
University of British Columbia law professor Michael Jackson and Graham Stewart, who recently retired after decades as head of the John Howard Society of Canada, prepared the report.
A panel led by Rob Sampson, a former corrections minister in Ontario's Mike Harris government, drafted the government plan, which is being implemented by the Correctional Service.
In addition to constructing super prisons and implementing work programs, the program will eliminate gradual release and deny inmates rights that are now entrenched in the constitution.
By stressing punishment rather than rehabilitation, the plan ignores lessons of the past, which led to the prison riots and killings that dominated Canadian news in the early 1970s, said Jackson.
"My greatest fear is with this road map's agenda and its underlying philosophy, we will enter a new period of turmoil and violence in Canadian prisons," he said.
"I do fear that prisons will become more abusive, prisoners will become more frustrated and that we could go back to a time not only when the rule of law was absent but a culture of violence is the dominant way in which prisoners express their frustrations."
The Day in Photos
President Barack Obama uses a light sabre as he watches a demonstration of fencing with Tim Morehouse who won a silver medal in Men's Sabre Fencing at the Beijing Olympics, Wednesday, Sept. 16, 2009, during an event supporting Chicago's 2016 host city Olympic bid, on the South Lawn of the White House in Washington. At rear is Chicago Mayor Richard Daley, and first lady Michelle Obama.
AP Photo/Charles Dharapak
Leona Lewis performs during the VH1 Divas concert on Thursday, Sept. 17, 2009 in New York.
AP Photo/Jason DeCrow
Ein junger Seehund geniesst am Freitag, 18. September 2009, die Sonne im Zoo in Berlin. (AP Photo/Maya Hitij) -- A young seal soaks up the sun as he swims at the Berlin zoo on Friday, Sept. 18, 2009.
AP Photo/Maya Hitij
Poland's Li Qian focuses the ball during her women's singles fourth round match against Veronika Pavlovich from Belarus during the individual competition of the Table Tennis European Championships in Stuttgart, Germany, Friday, Sept. 18, 2009.
AP Photo/Daniel Maurer
Bob Barker meets Lucy the elephant at Edmonton's River Valley Zoo on Thursday, September 17, 2009. Barker has campaigning for Lucy transfer to an elephant reserve in California.
THE CANADIAN PRESS/Ian Jackson
Members of "gulabi gang," (pink gang), a women's vigilante group, shout slogans at a protest in New Delhi, India, Thursday, Sept. 17, 2009 as they demand a separate Bundelkhand state. The group so named after the pink dress that they wear was formed in Uttar Pradesh State's Banda district. The women brandish sticks and fight for social issues.
AP Photo/Mustafa Quraishi
Farmers spray milk on a field in Ciney, Belgium, Wednesday, Sept. 16, 2009. Farmers in Belgium dumped 3 million liters (790,000 gallons) of fresh milk on a field to underscore that European producers can't make a living from current rock-bottom milk prices.
AP Photo/Virginia Mayo
Cast member Jennifer Aniston arrives at the premiere of "Love Happens" in Los Angeles on Tuesday, Sept. 15, 2009.
AP Photo/Matt Sayles
Malia Obama, daughter of President Barack Obama, waits at the South Portico of the White House with family dog Bo for his arrival on the South Lawn of the White House in Washington, Tuesday, Sept. 15, 2009.
AP Photo/Gerald Herbert
New York Yankees Derek Jeter, far left, rushes out towards on-deck batter Johnny Damon, (wearing helmet) as Yankees Jorge Posada (20) pushes home plate umpire Jim Joyce out of the way during an eighth inning brawl between the Yankees and the Toronto Blue Jays at Yankee Stadium Tuesday, Sept. 15, 2009 in New York.
AP Photo/Kathy Willens
The plan attempts to emulate the American "get tough" system, which incarcerated hundreds of thousands of people and has left some states on the verge of bankruptcy, said Stewart.
He called the plan "an ideological rant. All their recommendations are just that they believe in something.… There's no evidence for anything they recommend, there's no research, no background."
The federal road map flies in the face of the Correctional Service's own research of what works to rehabilitate prisoners and ensure community safety, said Stewart.
"The fact is that you cannot hurt a person and make them into a good citizen at the same time."
The government has already allocated hundreds of millions to the plan, even though it has had no input from either Parliament or the public, according to the report.
75 %
25 %
